Kenneth Lowande
8 min
This review evaluates the recent trend in American political scholarship, specifically focusing on William Howell and Terry Moe’s 'Trajectory of Power: The Rise of the Strongman Presidency.' The author highlights a broader reorientation within the discipline, where scholars have increasingly moved away from traditional, objective political science toward overt political advocacy in response to the rise of Donald Trump. While the author acknowledges the understandable impulse to address urgent democratic crises, they argue that this shift in scholarship is counterproductive. Instead of providing clear, evidence-based solutions, this trend often results in works that validate preexisting partisan biases while failing to meet the standards of scientific rigor necessary for a deep understanding of institutional change.
Howell and Moe argue that the Republican party is uniquely responsible for weakening democratic guardrails to achieve their political goals, viewing the administrative state as a fundamentally progressive instrument that Republicans must dismantle. The review disputes this 'asymmetric logic,' noting that it fails to explain why Republicans would pursue reforms that could paradoxically undermine their own long-term interests, such as the effectiveness of national security and defense agencies. Furthermore, the author critiques the book's reliance on 'impressionistic' historical narratives that lack transparent standards of evidence, suggesting that alternative narratives could easily be constructed from the same set of events to support different conclusions.
Beyond specific methodological concerns, the author contends that political advocacy by scholars is ineffective at influencing public opinion or policy. Because voters are rarely swayed by academic cues, such work risks exacerbating the existing 'academic sectarianism'—the perception that universities are merely partisan enclaves. This environment erodes trust in scientific expertise and fails to offer the precise, generalizable knowledge required for effective institutional reform.
To address this, the review advocates for a return to the 'revolution' in presidential studies that prioritized breaking down complex institutional functions—such as vetoes, appointments, and agency design—into manageable, observable parts. By adopting transparent data collection and rigorous, objective analysis, researchers can better navigate the complexities of the current political moment without sacrificing the integrity of the discipline. The author concludes that such an approach is essential for studying the American presidency, which remains the most important political office in the world.
Sam: Start with government functions Republicans value. Weakening institutional safeguards could also damage defense agencies, reliable benefit payments, or tornado prediction. Lowande asks why those costs wouldn’t discourage Republican presidents from pursuing extraordinary control.
Alex: There’s also the successor problem. If you expand presidential power, the other party could inherit it.
Sam: That’s his next challenge. Why accept the risk of a future Democratic strongman? The book’s logic might work if Republicans saw ordinary administration as hopelessly progressive, but Lowande disputes that starting point too.
Alex: Because agencies don’t all work the same way? Treating the whole bureaucracy as one political actor seems like a consequential simplification.
Sam: He argues that administration is procedural, slow, and often resistant to change. Those features can frustrate progressive goals while benefiting established business interests. His example is nuclear regulation, which can disappoint both advocates of stricter standards and supporters of faster licensing.
Alex: Those objections identify missing mechanisms. But they don’t establish that Republicans and Democrats behave identically.
Sam: They don’t. Lowande is arguing that this explanation hasn’t adequately established its central claim. An unanswered question weakens an account; it doesn’t automatically prove its opposite.
Alex: Let’s make his method concrete. Where can we hear the difference between describing events and actually establishing the explanation?
Sam: His central example concerns the Environmental Protection Agency. Howell and Moe describe litigation seeking vehicle carbon-emissions regulation as an effort to make the agency simply do its job. They present the relevant statutory language as clear.
Alex: And Lowande thinks that wording settles a political dispute before the analysis begins?
Sam: He argues that the law leaves substantial questions about which pollutants to regulate and how. If the agency has discretion, a Republican administration’s different policy could represent legitimate political contestation, rather than sabotage. Distinguishing those interpretations requires more than assuming the agency has one obvious job.
Alex: That makes the key issue observable. If your definition of proper agency performance already favors one policy, departures can look like institutional destruction by definition.
Sam: That’s his concern about normative assumptions: judgments about what ought to happen. He doesn’t claim researchers can have no values. He wants those judgments separated from explanations of what happened and why.
Alex: How does that become a criticism of the book’s evidence? Historical research can be rigorous without estimating an effect.
Sam: Lowande explicitly agrees. His criticism is that the book supplies no case-selection strategy, no measurement framework for key concepts, and no standards for evidence against its argument. He wants historical cases to test implications, not merely illustrate a persuasive story.
Alex: Does he offer a competing interpretation of the same history? That would show why the distinction matters.
Sam: He points to Nicholas Jacobs and Sidney Milkis, whose account emphasizes Republican presidents redeploying administration for conservative ends, rather than destroying it. Lowande allows that the accounts might be reconciled. His question is what shared evidentiary standard would decide between them.
Alex: Now let’s apply that demand to Lowande himself. How much evidence supports his larger warning about advocacy?
Sam: That’s where we should distinguish his arguments. His close reading exposes assumptions and alternative interpretations. His claim that scholarly advocacy is unlikely to persuade, and could damage trust, relies on surrounding research rather than a direct test of advocacy by scholars.
Alex: What does that surrounding research cover? Evidence about campaign persuasion isn’t automatically evidence about a researcher’s book.
Sam: He cites work on trusted sources and uncertainty, low confidence in higher education, and a campaign-contact analysis drawing on forty-nine field experiments. Those support his reasons for skepticism. They don’t directly measure whether books like this change political attitudes or trust.
Alex: He also describes a decline in presidency research. Is that evidence of damage from the turn toward advocacy?
Sam: He explicitly says that connection is unclear. He cites a comparison reporting less than half as many presidency articles in journals in 2023 as in 2009. But this excerpt gives neither underlying counts nor the journal sample, so that statistic needs cautious interpretation.
Alex: What does he recommend instead? Surely not ignoring institutional change until researchers have historical distance.
Sam: He says Trump warrants special attention, while making inference especially difficult because the political rules themselves are unsettled. His alternative is to study presidential tools separately, with explicit assumptions, transparent evidence, and openness to contradiction. He also sees an opportunity in abundant government data and newer computational tools.
Alex: So who should read the full essay, and where should they start?
Sam: Researchers studying political institutions, and anyone combining scholarship with advocacy. Start with the environmental-agency discussion in “The Asymmetric Logic of the Presidency,” then read “Narratives as Evidence.” Together, they show how a contested interpretation becomes an evidentiary problem.
Alex: And what should everyone else carry away, without treating this review as the final word?
Sam: Lowande offers a methodological challenge, not a definitive test of advocacy’s consequences. His most useful demand travels beyond presidential studies: the more urgently we need an explanation, the more carefully we should test it.
Alex: Thanks for listening.