Virgil Zeigler-Hill, Avi Besser, Stephanie E Jett
8 min
This paper examines humor as an interpersonal signal—a trait that communicates an individual's underlying qualities and social value to others. Using a two-dimensional framework (benign vs. injurious; self-directed vs. other-directed), the researchers investigated whether these distinct humor styles influence how people are perceived by friends, family, and potential romantic partners.
The authors hypothesize that humor evolved as a mating display, similar to elaborate physical traits in other species, to signal genetic fitness, intelligence, and social resourcefulness. By identifying four specific styles—affiliative, self-enhancing, aggressive, and self-defeating—the researchers sought to move beyond the simplistic notion of having a general "good sense of humor" to understand what specific signals these styles broadcast to the social environment.
In Study 1, using a one-with-many design, researchers found that friends and family members formed distinct impressions based on the target's humor. Those who displayed benign humor (affiliative and self-enhancing) were rated as having higher self-esteem, better personality traits, and lower aggression. Conversely, individuals who used injurious humor (aggressive and self-defeating) were perceived more negatively.
Study 2 focused on romantic desirability. Participants read personality profiles depicting different humor styles and evaluated the targets. The results mirrored Study 1: individuals described as using benign humor were consistently ranked higher in romantic appeal, warmth, and status, while those characterized as having an aggressive humor style were rated as significantly less desirable, likely because their humor signaled undesirable aggressive traits.
These findings suggest that humor is not a uniform positive trait. Instead, the specific style of humor serves as an honest, meaningful signal that acts as a gatekeeper in relationship formation. For students of psychology and evolutionary biology, this work highlights that our social judgments are heavily influenced by the specific mechanisms through which people express humor, revealing that not all humor facilitates social cohesion or romantic attraction.
OBJECTIVE: The provision of information appears to be an important feature of humor. The present studies examined whether humor serves as an interpersonal signal such that an individual's style of humor is associated with how the individual is perceived by others. METHOD: We examined this issue across two studies. In Study 1, undergraduate participants (257 targets) were rated more positively by their friends and family members (1194 perceivers) when they possessed more benign humor styles. In Study 2, 1190 community participants rated the romantic desirability of targets ostensibly possessing different humor styles. RESULTS: Across both studies, our results were consistent with the possibility that humor serves as a signal. More specifically, individuals with benign humor styles (affiliative and self-enhancing humor styles) were evaluated more positively than those targets with injurious humor styles (aggressive and self-defeating humor styles). CONCLUSION: These findings are discussed in terms of the role that humor may play in interpersonal perception and relationships.
Alex: Familiar observers bring useful information, but also established opinions. What did they rate besides humor?
Sam: They rated self-esteem, personality traits, aggression, and aspects of narcissism, including entitlement and grandiose self-beliefs. There were 1,194 observers altogether. Their humor ratings used shortened versions of the students’ questionnaire.
Alex: What does an item actually ask? That would help distinguish a humor style from a general impression of niceness.
Sam: One self-report item says, “If someone makes a mistake, I will often tease them about it.” Observers answered a corresponding question about the student. Other items covered joking with friends, cheering yourself up, or letting people laugh at your expense.
Alex: Multiple observers rated each student, so those judgments are not independent. How did the analysis handle that?
Sam: The authors used multilevel models, accounting for observers being grouped around the same student. One comparison asked whether an observer seeing more aggressive humor than other observers also saw more aggression. Another linked students’ self-reports with their average ratings from others.
Alex: Before connecting humor with personality, did students and observers even agree about the humor?
Sam: They agreed, but not perfectly. The correlations ranged from roughly point two eight for self-enhancing humor to point four three for affiliative humor. Observers distinguished the harmful styles more clearly than the benign styles.
Alex: So this is not just students assigning themselves a flattering label. Their descriptions had some correspondence with how people around them saw them.
Sam: And benign humor generally accompanied more favorable judgments. For example, students reporting more self-enhancing humor were seen as having higher self-esteem and emotional stability, and less aggression. Self-reported aggressive humor was associated with others seeing more entitlement and aggression.
Alex: But someone could already seem aggressive, and that could color how their teasing gets interpreted. The observational study cannot settle which impression drives which.
Sam: It cannot. The self-report links help because humor and other traits were not always rated by the same person. But they still do not establish that humor caused those broader impressions.
Alex: That makes the experiment important. What information did strangers receive, and what were they asked to judge?
Sam: The sample comprised 1,190 unmarried Jewish Israeli community participants, mostly in their twenties. They were randomly assigned a profile describing an other-sex potential partner. Each profile portrayed a particular humor style.
Alex: Were these actual people telling jokes, or descriptions saying what their humor was like?
Sam: Descriptions created by the researchers. Participants were told these were personality profiles based on interviews and psychological measures from an earlier study. They then rated the described person's romantic desirability.
Alex: So random assignment tests the effect of receiving a description, not the effect of hearing a joke. What counted as romantic desirability?
Sam: Ratings covered warmth and trustworthiness, attractiveness and vitality, and status and resources. The authors also asked about overall attractiveness and value as a potential relationship partner. Those are perceptions of the described person, not verified qualities.
Alex: Did the styles produce one consistent ordering, or did an abrasive profile look appealing on some dimensions?
Sam: The ordering was consistent across those outcomes. Affiliative and self-enhancing profiles were rated more positively than self-defeating profiles. Aggressive profiles received the least favorable ratings, including lower warmth and trustworthiness.
Alex: How substantial was the difference? A large sample can make a small distinction look statistically convincing.
Sam: For overall partner value, the reported humor-style effect size was partial eta squared of point three nine. That is substantial within this experiment. It describes differences between profile conditions, not the share of real-world romantic attraction explained by humor.
Alex: The profiles make the contrast clean, but real humor includes timing, delivery, and the relationship between people. Does the document acknowledge that gap?
Sam: Yes. The authors identify the artificial profiles as a limitation and call for subtler, more naturalistic tests. They also caution that skillful use could change impressions: self-deprecating comedians, for example, can come across as humble and charming.
Alex: And the signaling explanation has an evolutionary strand. Do these studies test whether humor indicates intelligence or genetic quality?
Sam: No. Those are proposed explanations discussed in the paper, not outcomes established here. Nor do these studies establish actual partner choices or long-term relationship success. Their strongest shared result concerns judgments, mostly of young adults.
Alex: So who should read the full document, and where should they start?
Sam: Researchers studying personality, impression formation, or romantic attraction should read it. Start with the experimental methods and romantic-desirability results, keeping the profile manipulation in mind. For familiar-person judgments, read the observational study’s analytic strategy: it separates differences among observers from differences among the people being rated.
Alex: And for someone who only needs the central lesson?
Sam: These studies suggest that friendly humor and humor that supports your own outlook invite more favorable judgments than putting yourself or others down. The line to remember is: a sense of humor is not one social signal; its style matters.
Alex: Thanks for listening.