Shae Datta, Brian S Im, Geraldine Pagnotta, Mara Sproul, Rebecca D Folkerth, Enna Selmanovic, Hector Arciniega
9 min
Former athletes frequently present to medical clinics asking if they have Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy (CTE). While public awareness of this condition has grown significantly due to media coverage and research, the clinical reality remains that CTE is a neuropathologically defined disease that can currently only be confirmed postmortem. This creates a substantial gap between patient expectations and the capabilities of modern neuroscience. Clinicians are tasked with navigating this "living uncertainty" while managing complex, often non-specific symptoms such as mood changes, cognitive impairment, or sleep disturbances that athletes often attribute to CTE.
Because no validated in vivo diagnostic test for CTE exists, clinicians must prioritize an athlete-centered approach. Instead of attempting to confirm or exclude a condition that cannot be diagnosed, the focus should shift toward addressing the patient's underlying concerns and potential drivers of their symptoms. This process involves a comprehensive evaluation of neurological, psychiatric, and psychosocial factors—such as sleep disorders, chronic pain, or mental health challenges—that are often treatable and may be driving the symptoms initially linked to suspected CTE. By acknowledging the limits of current diagnostics while offering actionable care, physicians can foster trust and improve the patient's quality of life.
Effective management requires an interdisciplinary model where neurology, psychiatry, and rehabilitation specialists coordinate care. Within this setting, clinicians can utilize shared decision-making and motivational interviewing to help patients navigate their health anxieties. These tools allow doctors to integrate scientific evidence with the athlete’s personal values and risk tolerance, especially regarding decisions like return-to-sport or continued athletic participation. This approach ensures that patients feel heard, validates their concerns without reinforcing unscientific conclusions, and establishes a path for longitudinal health management that does not depend on a definitive CTE diagnosis.
Athletes exposed to repetitive head impacts (RHI) may seek clinical evaluation because of concerns about chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a neuropathologically defined disease that cannot currently be diagnosed during life. As public awareness of CTE has expanded, clinicians face challenges communicating diagnostic uncertainty, interpreting non-specific symptoms, and addressing concerns about future neurological health. This Current Opinion examines the widening gap between public expectations and scientific capability and considers its implications for athlete-centered care. We discuss how clinicians can acknowledge uncertainty without dismissing patients' concerns, identify potentially treatable contributors to symptoms without prematurely attributing them to neurodegenerative disease, and use shared decision-making to guide individualized evaluation and management. We also consider how concerns about CTE may influence decisions about continued participation and return-to-sport among current athletes. Meeting these challenges requires coordinated interdisciplinary care, evidence-based communication, and clinical approaches that prioritize meaningful intervention even when diagnostic certainty remains unavailable.
Sam: One cited study examined about a thousand neurodegenerative brain-bank cases. Twenty-five individuals met the syndrome criteria. Of that group, only about a quarter had the defining CTE tissue changes. Diagnostic performance was largely driven by head-impact exposure rather than the proposed clinical features.
Alex: That is a selected brain-bank sample, not a survey of all athletes. It cannot tell us how common CTE is among people who played contact sports.
Sam: The article leaves that population question open. The comparison instead illustrates the difficulty of inferring pathology from a clinical syndrome. A separate community-based study offers another warning about symptom overlap.
Alex: What did that study compare, and does it address people outside the brain-bank setting?
Sam: It involved roughly three hundred people with traumatic brain injury. When researchers removed the repeated-head-impact requirement, about a third met all the syndrome’s core clinical features. There was no significant difference between participants with and without repeated-head-impact exposure.
Alex: So the concern is not that these symptoms are unreal. It is that the symptom pattern does not reliably identify its cause.
Sam: That distinction drives the article. Cognitive complaints, mood changes, sleep problems, and headaches deserve assessment. A history of repeated impacts plus nonspecific symptoms should not be treated as evidence of CTE.
Alex: Where is the new contribution, then? Coordinated care and careful differential diagnosis were not invented for this problem.
Sam: The authors do not claim they were. Interdisciplinary concussion centers already combine specialties. Their argument is to adapt those established approaches to a changing consultation: patients seeking certainty about feared degeneration, not only help recovering from an injury.
Alex: The feared explanation becomes part of the clinical problem. Does the article offer evidence that believing you have CTE matters independently of the symptoms?
Sam: It cites a study of living former professional football players. Those who believed they had CTE were approximately twice as likely to report suicidality as those who did not. That association remained after accounting for depression and other established predictors.
Alex: That cannot tell us whether the belief caused the distress. What do the authors say about the separate claim linking CTE itself to suicide?
Sam: They distinguish those questions. Cited postmortem research in contact-sport athletes did not identify a significant association between CTE pathology and suicide as a cause of death. The practical implication is to assess psychological distress and suicidality, not assume that feared brain disease explains them.
Alex: Let’s turn to the proposed clinical approach. How can a clinician take the concern seriously without implying that an unavailable diagnosis is likely?
Sam: First, identify what brought the athlete in. Is it a current symptom, fear of future cognitive decline, or uncertainty about past exposure? Those concerns overlap, but separating them allows treatment decisions without pretending to know the person’s future CTE risk.
Alex: The distinction is easier to understand with a symptom. If someone reports cognitive difficulty, what does the article suggest looking at instead of stopping at the CTE question?
Sam: It recommends considering sleep disorders, psychiatric conditions, medication effects, and other medical or psychosocial contributors. These may act separately or together. A lifetime head-trauma history should also include individual injuries and repeated impacts, both inside and outside sport.
Alex: That is broader than ruling out one disease. It also gives the patient something actionable while the underlying explanation remains uncertain.
Sam: Depending on the presentation, the authors suggest cognitive testing and targeted referrals across neurology, psychiatry, sleep medicine, and rehabilitation. They also recommend addressing modifiable risks for later cognitive decline, including high blood pressure, inactivity, excessive alcohol use, hearing loss, isolation, and depression.
Alex: Patients may still ask for a scan or blood test to settle the issue. How explicit should clinicians be about those options?
Sam: The authors say no imaging or fluid biomarker—a measurable biological indicator—is currently validated to diagnose CTE in an individual patient. Such tests should not be interpreted as confirming or excluding it. Research activity is not the same as clinical diagnostic readiness.
Alex: And once that limit is clear, the athlete still needs a say in what happens next. How do the authors organize those decisions?
Sam: Through shared decision-making: combining available evidence with the patient’s values and circumstances. With the athlete’s consent, family members can contribute observations about cognition, behavior, and daily functioning. The aim is an agreed plan, not simply a statement that certainty is unavailable.
Alex: Does that reasoning extend to athletes still competing, or does uncertainty make return-to-sport decisions impossible too?
Sam: The authors separate recovery after concussion from future CTE risk. Return-to-sport should follow current consensus recommendations, clinical recovery, and individualized assessment. Continued participation requires a broader discussion of cumulative exposure, uncertain long-term risks, personal priorities, and risk tolerance.
Alex: This sounds reasonable, but has the proposed approach been shown to improve outcomes specifically for athletes worried about CTE?
Sam: That is the main limitation: evidence specific to this population remains limited. This is an opinion article drawing on existing research and clinical principles, not a trial of the care model. The authors call for studies of psychological distress, healthcare engagement, and suicidality.
Alex: Given that boundary, who should read the full article, and where should they start?
Sam: Clinicians caring for athletes with head-impact histories should start with “Navigating Diagnostic Uncertainty Through Interdisciplinary Care.” Researchers studying diagnostic communication or care delivery should read it for the questions still needing evaluation. Then revisit the introduction’s comparison between syndrome criteria and tissue findings: that is the evidential reason for caution.
Alex: And what should someone outside this area carry back to their own work?
Sam: Keep uncertainty about disease separate from uncertainty about whether help is possible. The article does not offer a way to diagnose CTE during life. It argues that patients can still receive serious evaluation, treatment of identifiable problems, and a plan for follow-up. No definitive diagnosis does not mean no meaningful care.
Alex: Thanks for listening.