Alan Andrade, Kenneth Lowande, Abigail Paegert, Saloni Singh
9 min
American politics has undergone a significant realignment, where the Democratic party increasingly draws support from highly credentialed elites and the Republican party from non-college educated voters. This paper investigates whether this 'diploma divide' manifests within the White House staff—the central hub of U.S. executive policy. By analyzing records of nearly 6,000 White House staffers between 1995 and 2024, the authors examine how presidential administrations construct their governing coalitions through educational pedigree.
The authors find clear evidence that Democratic presidents consistently hire more credentialed staff than their Republican counterparts. Democratic staffers are significantly more likely to hold advanced degrees (M.A., J.D., or Ph.D.). In contrast, Republican presidents are more likely to hire individuals with degrees from public universities, institutions without R1 research status, and schools ranked outside the top 50%. These differences persist even after controlling for demographic factors like race, gender, and salary, suggesting that educational pedigree acts as a distinct marker of political alignment.
The study also explores whether these educational backgrounds influence government behavior. Specifically, the authors find that during the second Trump administration, universities whose alumni disproportionately staffed Democratic administrations were more likely to face investigations, enforcement actions, and reductions in federal research funding. These outcomes remained significant even when controlling for an institution's size, prestige, endowment, local political environment, and recent protest activity. This suggests that the educational backgrounds of political personnel are not merely symbolic but are associated with tangible, adversarial outcomes for institutions of higher education.
As executive action becomes an increasingly prominent tool for setting national policy, the people who staff the White House wield significant influence over government operations. Understanding the provenance and political leanings of these staffers is crucial for interpreting how modern presidencies interact with, reward, or punish established institutions. This research suggests that higher education has become a central battleground in American political polarization, with the credentials of those in power shaping the regulatory and financial landscape for universities.
Alex: Before getting to universities’ treatment, what is the clearest evidence that the staffs themselves differ?
Sam: About forty-one percent of Democratic staffers entered with advanced degrees. The Republican comparison was about thirty-one percent. So this is not mainly a divide between college graduates and everyone else; it is a credential divide within an already highly educated workplace.
Alex: Could that simply mean Democratic presidents employ more lawyers? Different job descriptions might require different qualifications.
Sam: That accounts for only part of the difference. Democrats employed somewhat more legal counsel, but not enough to explain the wider law-degree gap. The authors illustrate this with chiefs of staff: Biden hired Ron Klain, who held a law degree; Trump’s second administration hired Susie Wiles, who held a bachelor’s degree.
Alex: That example separates a person’s training from their job title. Did the broader credential difference survive comparisons beyond the kinds of jobs created?
Sam: Party remained a strong predictor after accounting for salary, year, sex, and race and ethnicity. The divide also extended to subjects studied. Democrats were more associated with fields including sociology and gender studies; Republicans with business, economics, and criminal justice.
Alex: Then the difference concerns both credentials and areas of expertise. What about the institutions themselves, rather than the subjects their alumni studied?
Sam: Republican staff were more likely to have attended public institutions, less highly ranked institutions, and institutions without the highest research classification. Democratic staff were more concentrated in prestigious educational settings. These are differences in educational backgrounds, not a test of which staff were more capable.
Alex: Now to the policy connection. How do they turn those individual records into a university-level measure without simply rewarding institutions that produced more staff overall?
Sam: They construct what they call Democratic alumni lean: the balance of Democratic versus Republican White House service associated with each institution. They adjust for the unequal time each party held the presidency in their records. Their models also account for the institution’s total staff connections.
Alex: And “Democratic” here means serving a Democratic president, rather than a separately measured political identity. What do they compare that institutional balance against?
Sam: They compare it with actions under Trump’s second administration in twenty twenty-five. One analysis uses publicly reported letters, visits, investigations, and enforcement actions against particular colleges and universities. Institutions with a stronger Democratic alumni lean were more likely to face action, even after adjustment for other observed differences.
Alex: Prestigious universities also differ in wealth, location, and campus politics. How much of that competing explanation did the authors actually address?
Sam: They account for enrollment, endowment, ranking, public or private status, and research classification. They also include county-level support for Trump and recorded pro-Palestinian protest activity. The alumni association remains, although Republican-leaning institutions were not exempt from scrutiny.
Alex: Public reporting could be uneven, though. The document itself raises the possibility that actions against conservative institutions might receive less publicity. Is there another outcome?
Sam: They also examine research grant and contract terminations from the National Science Foundation and National Institutes of Health. Those records combine researcher reports with government data. The funding models additionally account for institutions’ existing federal research funding, rather than treating every university as equally exposed.
Alex: What does the funding result mean in everyday terms? A statistically detectable association could still be financially minor.
Sam: A standard-deviation increase in Democratic alumni lean was associated with about fifteen percent more research dollars lost. That describes a sizable shift in their alumni measure. It does not mean an institution lost that share of its entire research budget.
Alex: We have a staffing difference and an adjusted association with government action. What most limits the conclusion we should draw from them?
Sam: The design cannot identify the causal pathway. Politically inclined students might select particular schools. Hiring managers might use educational backgrounds as signals of loyalty or competence. Policy priorities could shape both hiring and university treatment, while alumni networks might also influence decisions.
Alex: So the evidence cannot tell us whether officials protected their own institutions, punished perceived opponents, or followed priorities correlated with those educational networks. There is also missing education information. How serious is that?
Sam: Education is unknown for nearly a quarter of staffers. Missing records are more common for Republican staff and lower-paid positions; the authors argue that probably understates the credential gap. But that argument does not recover the missing information. And recording only the highest degree leaves earlier institutional ties unmeasured.
Alex: Given those limits, who should read the full document, and where would you send them first?
Sam: Researchers studying executive personnel, political networks, or higher-education policy should read it. Start with “The White House Diploma Divide” to understand the underlying sorting. Then read “White House Alumni and Targeting,” especially the funding analysis and its adjustments, before returning to the personnel-data limitations.
Alex: And for someone who only needs the central finding, what should survive after the methodological details fade?
Sam: Educational sorting reaches the people who operate presidential power. This study finds that universities’ connections to those people also track their exposure to federal action—but it does not establish why.
Alex: Keep that distinction in mind.