Kenneth Lowande
9 min
This paper examines the changing landscape of American political science, specifically focusing on the recent trend of scholars adopting explicitly normative goals in their work. The author uses William G. Howell and Terry Moe’s book, Trajectory of Power: The Rise of the Strongman Presidency, as a primary case study. The author argues that much of the contemporary academic literature has moved away from the traditional, impartial study of institutions toward a model of political advocacy aimed at raising alarm bells about democratic backsliding and the presidency of Donald Trump.
The author contends that this reorientation has significant costs for the field. By reviewing the arguments in Trajectory of Power, the author illustrates how reliance on normative historical description can lead to the neglect of rigorous empirical standards. The article critiques the book’s central thesis—that Republican presidents are uniquely responsible for the erosion of institutional guardrails—as being unsupported by sufficient evidence and reliant on contestable, ideologically charged assumptions about the nature of the administrative state.
The paper posits that the current political moment requires more, not less, commitment to the core tenets of political science: clear reasoning, transparent data collection, and objective analysis. The author argues that when research is designed to validate pre-existing partisan beliefs, it alienates potential audiences and further erodes public trust in expertise. Instead of engaging in advocacy, the author calls for a return to the scholarly tradition of breaking down complex institutions into manageable, testable components.
The author concludes that the study of the American presidency remains vital, especially given the unprecedented access to new data and computational tools. By citing models like Cameron and Kastellec’s work on the Supreme Court, the article suggests that scholars can still address the most pressing questions of the day by maintaining a strict separation between descriptive analysis and normative reform proposals. This approach ensures that findings remain useful to a broad range of stakeholders regardless of their political orientation.
Alex: His stated objection concerns the evidence and reasoning, not unequal blame alone. He calls the argument new and provocative. But he asks whether its proposed incentives actually explain the institutional changes, and whether the evidence distinguishes that account from alternatives.
Sam: Where does he think those incentives fail to add up?
Alex: Start with government functions Republicans value. Expanding political control can also damage military effectiveness, intelligence work, or basic administration. Lowande asks why Republicans would choose institutional changes that undermine functions they want to preserve.
Sam: There is also the next election. More presidential power could become power for a Democratic successor.
Alex: That is his next objection: the “shadow of the future,” meaning consequences after the other party takes office. Why accept that risk? One possible answer is that Republicans see the existing bureaucracy as so progressive that almost anything would be preferable.
Sam: But that depends on treating the bureaucracy as consistently hostile to conservative goals. Does he accept that premise?
Alex: No. He stresses that the administrative state is not one thing. Agencies can be slow, procedural, and resistant to change. Those features can frustrate progressive ambitions, while organized business interests can benefit from regulatory procedures.
Sam: So he wants an explanation for why these actors would surrender advantages and accept future risks, not just examples of aggressive presidents.
Alex: Yes, and that leads to his central methodological point. A narrative can describe events persuasively without establishing the mechanism that produced them. To see the difference, consider his example involving the Environmental Protection Agency.
Sam: That sounds like a place where policy disagreement and institutional damage could be difficult to separate. How does the example work?
Alex: Howell and Moe describe efforts to make the agency regulate vehicle carbon emissions as making it “simply do its job.” They say the Clean Air Act’s language is clear. Lowande objects that the wording leaves substantial discretion about pollutants, standards, and decisions.
Sam: So calling a Republican administration’s behavior “sabotage” may already assume a particular answer about what the agency ought to do.
Alex: That is his argument. He calls such assumptions normative: judgments about what ought to happen. If the agency’s mandate permits disagreement, some behavior described as sabotage might instead be legitimate policy contestation. The example challenges the classification; it does not settle every disputed agency action.
Sam: What evidence would help distinguish those interpretations? Historical research cannot always produce a clean experiment.
Alex: Lowande explicitly says this is not an objection to qualitative research. He asks for clear case selection, defined concepts, and standards for what would count against the explanation. His criticism is that the book illustrates its argument rather than testing implications that could fail.
Sam: Does he show why that distinction matters, beyond a general preference for more explicit methods?
Alex: He contrasts the book with Nicholas Jacobs and Sidney Milkis’s account. They argue that Republican presidents redeploy the administrative state for conservative purposes, rather than destroy it. Lowande says these narratives might even be reconcilable, but readers need standards for deciding between them.
Sam: That exposes uncertainty in the book’s explanation. It does not demonstrate that the explanation is false.
Alex: Correct. This is a review essay, not a new empirical test of the competing accounts. Its strongest contribution is identifying questions the explanation must answer. The broader claim that advocacy harms scholarship and public trust deserves separate scrutiny.
Sam: What supports that broader claim? Persuading readers and explaining institutions are different objectives.
Alex: Lowande draws on research suggesting persuasion works best when audiences are uncertain and trust the source. He argues those conditions fit poorly here. He also cites research finding minimal campaign persuasion, including an analysis of forty-nine field experiments.
Sam: Campaign messages are not academic books, though. Does the essay directly test whether scholarly advocacy changes political attitudes or trust?
Alex: Not in the excerpt we have. His warning extrapolates from research on persuasion, public trust, and academic political leanings. The possibility that advocacy alienates people without persuading them is an argued risk, not a directly measured effect of these books.
Sam: Then what does he recommend researchers do instead? Avoiding advocacy cannot mean avoiding consequential questions.
Alex: He explicitly rejects that retreat. He wants researchers to break presidential power into manageable parts and study them transparently. He points to earlier work on appointments, vetoes, war powers, and other presidential tools as a productive tradition.
Sam: The title suggests that tradition is under threat. Is there evidence that attention to the presidency is declining?
Alex: Lowande cites a count in which presidency articles in prestigious political science journals fell to less than half their earlier level. That compares 2023 with 2009. But he says it is unclear whether this decline relates to the turn toward advocacy.
Sam: So who should read the full essay, and where should they begin?
Alex: Researchers studying presidential power, institutional change, or politically charged questions. Start with “Narratives as Evidence,” then “The Study of the Presidency After Trump.” Read for the distinction between a convincing account and evidence that can discriminate between accounts. Treat the claims about advocacy’s consequences as arguments needing further testing.
Sam: And what should everyone else carry away?
Alex: Political urgency should raise the standard of evidence, not lower it. Lowande’s challenge is to produce research that can correct our preferred explanation, not merely give it a stronger voice.
Sam: That is a useful test to bring back to our own work.