ResearchPod Summary
This study examines the evolution of Haw Par Villa, a long-standing Singaporean themed space, through the lens of relational materialism and assemblage theory. By moving away from traditional, linear developmental models of tourism, the researchers treat the park as an 'assemblage'—a dynamic, heterogeneous collection of human agents, statues, discourses, and institutional efforts. The paper specifically applies Manuel DeLanda’s version of assemblage theory to analyze how the personal desires and linguistic imprints (such as the founder's name and original moral messaging) created a persistent identity that resisted external attempts at reconfiguration.
Haw Par Villa was established by Aw Boon Haw as a gift for his brother, designed to promote moral education and his 'Tiger Balm' brand. The study traces how this foundational vision created an identity that proved remarkably resilient. Whenever the state or private operators attempted to 'deterritorialize' or rebrand the park—such as the creation of the failed 'Dragon World' theme park or the 'Hua Song' museum—these efforts often collapsed because they lacked congruence with the original social and material identity. The researchers argue that the site's 'hell' statues, while originally intended for moral instruction, became deeply embedded in the collective memory of locals, forming a 'linguistic material' that acted as a barrier against top-down interventions.
This paper contributes to a more nuanced understanding of tourism sustainability that accounts for distributed agency rather than just state control. It highlights how even in highly controlled tourism environments like Singapore, the 'sideways' power of historical identity and local sentiment can override massive state-funded efforts at modernization. By focusing on the interplay between personal desires and physical materiality, the study provides a valuable framework for scholars to analyze how other culture-based attractions can drift into precarity or sustain themselves across different eras.
Alex: Owning a tourist attraction does not mean controlling what it means. A study of Singapore’s Haw Par Villa argues that reinventions struggled when they conflicted with the founder’s aims, surviving statues, and visitors’ memories.
Sam: So this is about why changing an attraction’s buildings and branding might not change its identity?
Alex: Yes. It’s a historical case study by Simin Xu and Chin-Ee Ong, published in Tourism Geographies in 2024. They trace a garden of Chinese mythological statues through commercial redevelopment, financial losses, and attempts at revival.
Sam: That matters for heritage researchers and anyone planning redevelopment. A place’s past might resist the future its managers want.
Alex: And the authors ask us to look beyond management decisions. We’ll follow one failed reinvention, examine how they reconstructed its history, and separate a persuasive interpretation from a proven explanation.
Sam: Start with the place itself. What was there before the reinventions?
Alex: Aw Boon Haw created the villa as a gift for his brother, who helped develop Tiger Balm ointment. Alongside the residence, he built gardens filled with statues teaching traditional Chinese morals. The gardens also advertised the ointment.
Sam: So it combined a family gift, commercial promotion, and public education from the beginning.
Alex: And free entertainment. The gardens opened to the public in 1937. The brothers’ names supplied the tiger and leopard motifs, tying the physical place to its founders.
Sam: Heritage studies already examine memory and symbolism. What does this study add to that account?
Alex: Earlier Haw Par Villa studies examined global-local tensions, culturally shaped tourist gazes, and developmental stages. These authors use relational materialism: studying how people and material things jointly shape outcomes. Their emphasis is how those relationships persist and change across the site’s history.
Sam: What does that mean in practice? Statues cannot object to a redevelopment plan.
AI-generated third-party summary by ResearchPod. Not official content or an endorsement by the paper authors or affiliated organizations.
Alex: They cannot object verbally. But their appearance, placement, and survival affect what visitors can do and what they remember. The authors call this an assemblage: an interacting combination of people, objects, language, and social processes.
Sam: So instead of treating the attraction as one thing, they follow the relationships that hold its identity together.
Alex: That’s the central move, drawing on Manuel DeLanda’s interpretation of assemblage theory. He calls processes that pull components together and stabilise an identity territorialisation. Here, that means more than securing a boundary: names, statues, and visitors’ practices can all reinforce the place.
Sam: Give me a visitor practice that actually depended on the material setting.
Alex: Parents stopped before graphic punishment scenes and used them to teach children not to lie, cheat, or behave unfilially. Interviewees recalled being frightened by figures having tongues pulled out or being lowered into boiling oil. The moral lesson depended partly on standing before those statues.
Sam: That also sounds like an identity that could become difficult to update.
Alex: Yes, and the authors show that both continuity and change could create problems. At its earlier peak, Haw Par Villa attracted 31 percent of Singapore’s tourists. It was among the country’s leading attractions, despite reports of deteriorating statues.
Sam: If it already attracted visitors, what was redevelopment supposed to achieve?
Alex: Singapore wanted to strengthen tourism after falling arrivals. The state acquired the land, and commercial operators were brought in to develop a Chinese mythological theme park called Dragon World. That introduced a different commercial ambition into the existing attraction.
Sam: A Chinese mythology theme sounds compatible with Chinese mythological statues. Where did the mismatch arise?
Alex: In what changed, not just the category on the label. Tiger and leopard motifs were downplayed, and a huge dragon became the emblem. Statues judged irrelevant were moved out of sight, while robots with American accents narrated the attraction.
Sam: And the parents’ practice of stopping before punishment scenes would not necessarily survive a theme-park format.
Alex: The authors make that connection explicitly. Hell became a thrill ride, shifting attention toward excitement rather than parental moral instruction. Admission also cost sixteen Singapore dollars, replacing a place many locals remembered as free.
Sam: That gives us several explanations at once: price, altered experiences, lost memories, and unfamiliar presentation. How did the researchers investigate them?
Alex: They combined a site visit with archives, newspaper coverage, oral histories, books, films, and online materials. They also interviewed twenty-three Singaporean respondents, prioritising people who had visited at different stages of life. The historical account spans about eighty-five years.
Sam: Were those interviews intended to represent Singaporean opinion, or to recover particular experiences?
Alex: To recover experiences across ages and repeated visits. Selection was purposeful, with respondents also recommending friends or relatives. Both authors separately coded the collected material, then discussed and negotiated their themes.
Sam: That offers depth, but it is not a representative survey. And remembering childhood gives a different kind of evidence from observing reactions at the time.
Alex: My reading is that the mixed sources strengthen the historical interpretation, not a clean causal estimate. This is one retrospectively reconstructed case. It cannot isolate how much commercial failure came from identity conflict rather than pricing or other changing conditions.
Sam: Did everyone reject Dragon World, or did the reinvention create its own attachments?
Alex: It created attachments too. Some respondents who visited as young children remembered Dragon World happily. Returning as adults, they were disappointed that its rides and dragon entrance had disappeared.
Sam: That complicates the argument. Restoring an older version could recover one generation’s memories while erasing another’s.
Alex: And the study preserves that complication. Operators brought back the original name, returned displaced statues, restored hell as a walkway, and lowered admission charges. Losses nevertheless continued, and the attraction eventually became free again.
Sam: So the practical lesson cannot just be to return everything to the founder’s plan.
Alex: No. Singapore’s leisure options expanded, and free admission became less distinctive. Parenting attitudes changed too: some interviewees now saw the punishment scenes as unsuitable for children. The same objects could endure while the desires surrounding them changed.
Sam: Did later operators find ways to work with that inherited identity rather than replace it?
Alex: They tried seasonal events that used the attraction’s scary reputation. Pokémon Go briefly drew players to its ghost-type creatures, and social media encouraged photographic visits. But the authors report that seasonal events did not establish reasons to return.
Sam: What does the study leave unresolved about the attraction’s future?
Alex: In 2021, the Ten Courts of Hell became part of a paid museum about death cultures. The surrounding grounds remained free. The authors see that separation as another potential destabilisation, not a change whose long-term consequences they have established.
Sam: Who should read the full document, and where should they begin?
Alex: Researchers studying heritage, themed attractions, or redevelopment should start with the Dragon World section. It makes the people-object relationships concrete, including the conflicting memories. Then read the methodology to judge how the historical sources and interviews support the argument.
Sam: And what should everyone else remember?
Alex: A new owner can change a place faster than people change what it means. This case shows why inherited identities deserve investigation, not an assumption that either state plans or restoration will prevail.
Sam: Thanks for listening.