ResearchPod Summary
This paper serves as a rebuttal to the book Merit and Moses: A Critique of the Klinean Doctrine of Republication. The author, a former student and colleague of Meredith G. Kline, addresses charges that Klinean covenant theology constitutes an intolerable deviation from the Westminster Standards. The author argues that the critics of Kline rely on a faulty methodological framework that ignores both the exegetical basis for Kline’s work and the historical-theological diversity inherent in the 17th-century Reformed tradition.
Central to the author’s critique is the assertion that Merit and Moses characterizes Kline’s definition of merit as 'voluntaristic'—meaning merit is whatever God arbitrarily dictates, independent of his nature as a God of justice. The author contends that this is a significant misrepresentation. According to the author, Kline consistently tethered his concept of merit to the divine character. Furthermore, the author clarifies that when Kline discusses merit in the post-Fall context (the Mosaic economy), he refers specifically to 'typological merit'—a status where God invests the imperfect, faith-driven obedience of Old Testament figures with symbolic significance pointing toward the future messianic work of Christ.
The paper also disputes the 'plumb line and pendulum' analogy used by the book’s authors, which suggests that Kline developed his republication doctrine solely as a reactionary pivot against the theology of Norman Shepherd. The author demonstrates that Kline had established the core elements of his republication paradigm years before the Shepherd controversy, arguing instead that Kline was seeking to restore a view of the 'law covenant' that had been current in Reformed tradition prior to John Murray's mid-20th-century revisions of covenant theology.
Alex: Can imperfect obedience point toward perfect obedience without earning the same reward? Lee Irons argues that critics of theologian Meredith Kline confuse those claims, making Kline appear to say sinners can earn God’s blessings.
Sam: That sounds like a dispute over words with much larger consequences. What kind of document are we discussing?
Alex: It’s Irons’s response to Merit and Moses, a book criticizing Kline’s theology. Assembled from blog posts published in 2015, it defends Kline against charges of departing from Reformed doctrinal standards.
Sam: So the stakes include who gets counted as orthodox, not just how someone defines a word.
Alex: Yes. For researchers studying theology or confessional boundaries, it asks what evidence can justify excluding an interpretation. We’ll follow the central distinction, test the supporting quotations, and separate that defense from the larger questions it leaves open.
Sam: Start with the disputed position. What does Kline think happened in Israel’s relationship with God?
Alex: The term is republication: an earlier arrangement based on obedience reappears within the covenant given through Moses. A covenant here is an arrangement governing God’s relationship with people. The earlier arrangement is the covenant of works, promising reward on condition of obedience.
Sam: And the objection is that this arrangement cannot operate once people are sinful?
Alex: That’s central to the criticism Irons presents. Merit and Moses argues that after humanity’s fall into sin, God relates to sinners through a covenant of grace. That means salvation comes as God’s gift through faith in Christ, not through their earning it.
Sam: If Kline also accepts salvation by grace, where does his works requirement fit?
Alex: He distinguishes layers. At the underlying layer, believers receive eternal life through grace. At the upper, symbolic layer, Israel’s retention of its earthly inheritance in Canaan is governed by obedience. Irons says these involve different inheritances, not competing routes to the same salvation.
Separating the rewards helps. But it still leaves sinful people apparently earning something from God. How does Irons handle that?
This critique is significant for researchers exploring the development of modern covenant theology and the boundaries of orthodoxy within the Reformed tradition. By defending the two-layer interpretation of the Mosaic economy—which separates the typological layer from the underlying covenant of grace—the author attempts to demonstrate that the Klinean paradigm does not induce 'spiritual schizophrenia' in believers. Instead, the author argues that the typological framework serves a pedagogical, Christ-centered purpose, consistent with broader Pauline teaching and the historical breadth of Reformed thought.
AI-generated third-party summary by ResearchPod. Not official content or an endorsement by the paper authors or affiliated organizations.
Alex: Through typology: earlier people and institutions prefigure a later fulfillment. In Kline’s account, God gives certain imperfect acts symbolic significance. They point toward Christ’s perfect obedience without themselves possessing the same merit, meaning the capacity to earn the promised reward.
Sam: Can you give an example where Kline makes that difference explicit, rather than leaving Irons to reconstruct it?
Alex: Abraham is the clearest example. Kline describes Christ’s obedience as the ground of the eternal kingdom, then says, “Certainly, Abraham’s works did not have that status.” Abraham’s obedience instead receives an analogous value within the earlier, symbolic arrangement.
Sam: So Abraham’s obedience represents the basis of a later reward, without actually earning that later reward.
Alex: And Irons adds a crucial quotation about Israel’s arrangement as a whole. Kline calls it “a gracious favor to fallen sons of Adam.” He describes them as “deserving no blessings, temporal or eternal.” For Irons, that directly challenges the accusation that Kline makes sinners independently deserving.
Sam: What reasoning leads the critics to such a different reading?
Alex: As Irons summarizes them, they see a chain. Kline first redefines merit as “whatever God says it is.” God could therefore count imperfect obedience as meritorious, and Kline could extend that possibility to sinful Israelites.
Sam: Then the decisive question is whether Kline actually makes merit depend on an unrestricted divine choice.
Alex: Irons says he does not. He restores the context around Kline’s statement that God’s covenant word defines justice. In the longer passage, Kline repeatedly grounds the covenant’s terms in God’s perfect justice. Irons argues that this is revelation of justice, not arbitrary assignment of value.
Sam: That still sounds different from the critics’ definition. What do they require for genuine merit?
Alex: They require perfect obedience and ontological equality with God—equality in being. On that account, only Christ has strict merit. Adam’s possible obedience before the fall belongs to a lesser category, dependent on God’s voluntary condescension.
Sam: Does Irons reject both requirements, or only the equality requirement?
Alex: Only the equality requirement. He insists Kline requires perfection for true merit. Imperfect obedience has only typological merit, its appointed symbolic role. Irons’s charge is that the book treats those different uses of “merit” as interchangeable.
Sam: Is that distinction the new contribution here, or is Irons introducing a different theology?
Alex: He presents it as a correction to the book’s reading of Kline, not a new theological system. He also challenges its historical narrative. The book portrays Kline’s position as an overreaction to Norman Shepherd’s disputed teaching about faith, works, and justification—being declared righteous before God.
Sam: An overreaction story needs the chronology to work. What dates does Irons put against it?
Alex: He points to Kline’s book By Oath Consigned, published in 1968. That predates the controversy’s first sparks in 1975. The book already describes the Mosaic arrangement as contrasting law-based inheritance with inheritance by promise.
Sam: That would undermine the claim that the controversy originated the position, even if it later sharpened Kline’s language.
Alex: Irons allows precisely that sharpening. He also traces the position to Kline’s earlier article “Law Covenant.” His alternative account centers on disagreement with John Murray, who defined divine covenants as sovereign administrations of grace and promise.
Sam: There’s another issue beyond what Kline meant. Why should anyone accept the claim that works and grace can coexist without contradiction?
Alex: Irons turns to Paul’s letter to the Galatians. On his reading, the Mosaic law arrives after the promise to Abraham without cancelling it. The law exposes sin and directs people toward Christ. Its works principle therefore serves the promise rather than offering a rival means of salvation.
Sam: That also addresses the practical objection: Israelites might become entitled about earthly rewards while admitting dependence on grace for eternal life.
Alex: Irons answers that the whole national arrangement was an unearned gift. Ordinary believers also encountered their failure through the law and sought atonement through sacrifices. In his account, those sacrifices pointed to Christ, keeping the works requirement within a gracious setting.
Sam: How far should we trust this defense? Selected quotations can correct a misreading without settling an entire tradition’s boundaries.
Alex: That’s the distinction I’d make. The quotations provide concrete evidence against specific allegations about Kline. But the broader claim about permitted interpretations needs more historical work. Irons himself acknowledges lacking the expertise and source access to do that work well.
Sam: Does he at least demonstrate that earlier Reformed theologians held more than one position?
Alex: He supplies examples, including Samuel Bolton’s temporary covenant serving the gospel and Francis Turretin’s renewed presentation of the covenant of works. He explicitly says these writers were not simply Klineans before Kline. Their diversity challenges an exclusive reading; it does not establish agreement with every Klinean formulation.
Sam: Who should read the full response, and where should they begin?
Alex: Researchers in covenant theology, theological interpretation, or Reformed confessional history should read it. Start with the contextual quotations about merit, especially Abraham’s symbolic obedience. Then read “An Unstable Paradigm?” for the distinction between earthly and eternal inheritance. Compare the historical examples while keeping Irons’s acknowledged limits in view.
Sam: And what should someone outside that debate carry away?
Alex: Irons offers a committed defense, not an independent verdict on the controversy. But his central challenge is clear: before condemning a claim, establish what its key word means in context. Symbolic merit and true merit are not the same claim.
Sam: That distinction is a useful place to pause.