ResearchPod Summary
This essay examines the recent trend in political science scholarship, specifically within the study of the American presidency, to pivot from objective, empirical inquiry toward explicit political advocacy. Using William G. Howell and Terry Moe's book Trajectory of Power: The Rise of the Strongman Presidency (2025) as a primary case study, the author explores whether this shift toward normatively driven research improves our understanding of the current political crisis or undermines the credibility of the academic field.
Lowande contrasts the current academic climate with the preceding "revolution" in presidential studies, which emphasized rigorous, data-driven analysis of institutional constraints and executive tools. He evaluates Howell and Moe’s thesis—that Republican presidents have uniquely sought to dismantle administrative guardrails—against historical evidence and theoretical expectations about elite behavior. The author argues that because this work is built on contestable normative foundations, it lacks a transparent evidentiary standard and fails to account for the strategic incentives that might constrain all presidents, regardless of party.
The review contends that the current wave of "alarm-bell" scholarship produces narratives that are intellectually fragile and politically ineffective. By adopting an "asymmetric logic" that labels institutional conflict as partisan "sabotage," researchers bypass the need for rigorous hypothesis testing. Lowande suggests that this approach has significant costs: it does not generate actionable reform proposals, it fails to persuade the broader public, and it reinforces existing stereotypes of academia as a partisan enclave. The author argues that despite the gravity of the current political moment, scholars should return to the tradition of transparent, objective study, utilizing modern data and computational methods to analyze the presidency as an institution, rather than as a vehicle for ideological critique.
This critique serves as a call for introspection within the discipline of political science. As institutional stability faces real-world challenges, the author emphasizes that the academy’s primary contribution should be to provide a reliable, evidence-based understanding of power. By abandoning this mandate for the sake of political advocacy, scholars risk alienating their audience, damaging their credibility, and missing the opportunity to use new, unprecedented levels of accessible data to understand the most powerful office in the world.
AI-generated third-party summary by ResearchPod. Not official content or an endorsement by the paper authors or affiliated organizations.