ResearchPod Summary
This article serves as a guest editorial for a special issue of the Journal of Managerial Psychology, addressing how human resource management (HRM) can effectively navigate the increasingly diverse landscape of ethnic and religious cultural values. The authors examine the tension between universalistic HR models—which promote consistent policies to drive organizational goals like innovation and performance—and contingent models, which argue that HR practices must be tailored to the cultural value preferences of specific employee groups. Through a scoping review of 19 quantitative studies published in top-tier management journals between 2015 and 2025, the authors identify key patterns in how cultural values are currently measured and applied to HR functions.
The review highlights that research in this area is heavily concentrated on staffing and compensation, often relying on a narrow set of cultural dimensions (most frequently collectivism-individualism). The authors note a significant limitation in the field's reliance on country-level proxies for culture, which often ignores profound within-country variation and the impact of acculturation. The findings suggest that while aligning HR practices (like merit pay or recruitment sources) with cultural values can foster better individual outcomes, this approach introduces significant practical complexity and potential justice concerns. Ultimately, the authors argue that relying on static, group-level cultural stereotypes is becoming insufficient in a world where individuals hold intersecting, multi-faceted identities.
As global workforces become more diverse, HR professionals face the dual challenge of maintaining efficient, high-performance systems while ensuring inclusivity for employees with varying cultural and religious orientations. This research challenges HR scholars and practitioners to move beyond simple 'cultural fit' models. Instead, it advocates for a more sophisticated, evidence-based approach that considers cultural values as dynamic systems rather than isolated traits. By better understanding these interactions, organizations can build more resilient, equitable policies that honor individual differences without compromising strategic organizational objectives.
AI-generated third-party summary by ResearchPod. Not official content or an endorsement by the paper authors or affiliated organizations.